Which blackjack has the best odds? Under the rules shown, the lowest house edge belongs to ordinary blackjack with a generous rule set, and the variants sit close behind or well above it. The gap between games is often smaller than the gap between two tables of the same game. The same title can be a good game or a poor one depending on the small print, so which blackjack has the best odds depends on the rule card as much as the name.
Take four games that publish two documented versions. Atlantic City rules cost 0.36% (Atlantic City blackjack, dealer stands on soft 17. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 8 decks, dealer stands on soft 17, dealer checks for blackjack with a hole card, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any first two cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces are not resplit, one card to each split ace, late surrender. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money.) with the dealer standing on soft 17 and 0.56% (Atlantic City blackjack, dealer hits soft 17. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 8 decks, dealer hits soft 17, dealer checks for blackjack with a hole card, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any first two cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces are not resplit, one card to each split ace, late surrender. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money.) when the dealer hits it. Spanish 21 moves from 0.41% (Spanish 21, dealer stands on soft 17. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 6 decks of 48 cards (the ten-spot cards removed), dealer stands on soft 17, dealer checks for blackjack with a hole card, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any number of cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces may be resplit, split aces may be hit, late surrender, a doubled bet may be rescued, a player 21 beats a dealer 21, bonus payouts: 5-card 21 pays 3:2, 6-card 21 pays 2:1, 7-or-more-card 21 pays 3:1, 6-7-8 mixed pays 3:2, 6-7-8 suited pays 2:1, 6-7-8 in spades pays 3:1, 7-7-7 mixed pays 3:2, 7-7-7 suited pays 2:1, 7-7-7 in spades pays 3:1, bonuses are not paid on split hands. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money.) to 0.81% (Spanish 21, dealer hits soft 17. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 6 decks of 48 cards (the ten-spot cards removed), dealer hits soft 17, dealer checks for blackjack with a hole card, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any number of cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces may be resplit, split aces may be hit, late surrender, a doubled bet may be rescued, a player 21 beats a dealer 21, bonus payouts: 5-card 21 pays 3:2, 6-card 21 pays 2:1, 7-or-more-card 21 pays 3:1, 6-7-8 mixed pays 3:2, 6-7-8 suited pays 2:1, 6-7-8 in spades pays 3:1, 7-7-7 mixed pays 3:2, 7-7-7 suited pays 2:1, 7-7-7 in spades pays 3:1, bonuses are not paid on split hands. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money.) on the same rule. Free Bet Blackjack runs from 0.63% (Free Bet Blackjack, Nevada rules of play. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 6 decks, dealer hits soft 17, dealer checks for blackjack with a hole card, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any number of cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces may be resplit, one card to each split ace, no surrender, a dealer 22 pushes every hand still in play, free doubles on hard 9, 10 and 11 (any number of cards), free splits on every pair except fours and tens. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money. Free doubles and free splits are paid by the house, so they add to the result but not to the chips the player wagers.) under the Nevada rules of play to 1.02% (Free Bet Blackjack, dealer hits soft 17. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 6 decks, dealer hits soft 17, dealer checks for blackjack with a hole card, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any first two cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces may be resplit, one card to each split ace, no surrender, a dealer 22 pushes every hand still in play, free doubles on hard 9, 10 and 11 (first two cards), free splits on every pair except tens. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money. Free doubles and free splits are paid by the house, so they add to the result but not to the chips the player wagers.) with the dealer hitting soft 17. European Blackjack reads 0.41% (European Blackjack, a dealer blackjack takes the original bet only. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 6 decks, dealer stands on soft 17, no hole card, a dealer blackjack takes only the original bet, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any first two cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces are not resplit, one card to each split ace, no surrender. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money.) if a dealer natural takes only the original bet and 0.52% (European Blackjack, a dealer blackjack takes every bet. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 6 decks, dealer stands on soft 17, no hole card, a dealer blackjack takes every bet including doubles and splits, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any first two cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces are not resplit, one card to each split ace, no surrender. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money.) if it takes everything.
The top of the ranking is set by rules, not by names. The bottom is set by one rule. A single deck paying six to five costs 1.44% (Single deck blackjack paying 6 to 5. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 1 deck, dealer hits soft 17, dealer checks for blackjack with a hole card, blackjack pays 6:5, double on any first two cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces are not resplit, one card to each split ace, no surrender. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money.), more than double the comparison rules at 0.62% (Comparison rules: 6 decks, dealer hits soft 17, double after split, blackjack pays 3:2. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 6 decks, dealer hits soft 17, dealer checks for blackjack with a hole card, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any first two cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces are not resplit, one card to each split ace, no surrender. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money.) and nearly four times a double deck paying three to two at 0.39% (Double deck blackjack. House edge per starting bet: the average loss per round as a share of the bet placed before the cards are dealt, doubles and splits included in the result. Rules: 2 decks, dealer hits soft 17, no hole card, a dealer blackjack takes only the original bet, blackjack pays 3:2, double on any first two cards, double after split, split up to 4 hands, aces are not resplit, one card to each split ace, no surrender. The player follows the printed strategy chart for these rules from a full shoe, and never takes insurance or even money.). Fewer decks cannot rescue a short natural payout.
A low edge is not the same as a good evening. The figure says what a table keeps on average over a very long run, not what happens in a session, and games with bonus hands swing harder than plain ones. Read the edge as the price of the game and the twist as what you get for it.